What’s the right web content management system (CMS) for you?

Too Many Choices (courtesy of Pinto and the Bean)This is a tough question for most communicators. Sometimes it’s because they are unfamiliar with the technical aspects of a CMS. Sometimes it’s because there are too many choices out there. At ND, we have tons of different CMSes and it’s difficult to know which one will be the right one to choose. I know because I’ve had to help them make the choice before – for my past clients and for current clients.

So what are some good questions to ask yourself when you are picking your CMS?  I’ve got five questions that you should answer before buying one.

1. How easy is it to use?

This may seem like a silly question but if you want other people than yourself to put content on your website (which you should – there should never be a bottleneck of one content person), the CMS better we crazy easy to use. It should be “log in”, “select the page”, and “type into the content”, then “save” or “publish”. If you make it too hard or give people too many bells and whistles available, they won’t login again and they won’t help you load content.

BTW, if you have a system where only one person in your office can use the system at a time – that’s not good. Make sure the interface is easy and clear for someone who doesn’t play on the internet all day.

2. What are special content needs for my website?

We get this a lot.  People want a website but don’t know exactly what they’ll put in it.  You’ll save yourself and your team a ton of time, money and frustration if you just do some homework and get your content together first.

This way you’ll get a really, really (that’s two reallys) good understanding of what content is for your audiences. If you don’t have a good idea of the content, then you need to stop your CMS buying process and go back to the whiteboard. Laying out all your content will help inform your decision the best.

Well, what if you don’t know what all your content is.  What do you ask yourself to help you find all your content.  Here’s what I do.

Write down all the content you currently have, what it is and where it is. Text, video, photos, audio, pdfs or word documents, etc…  Is digital or in hard copy form?

Once you have it all down, think of how you’ll want to display it.

When it comes to video, do I want to use YouTube and embed it on the page or do I want people to download them and play them locally on their machine (I don’t recommend this)?

When it comes to photos, do I want to have them access to my flickr account? Do I want a photo gallery where they can see all the photos on my website? Do I want to make a slideshow? Or maybe display all photos in a lightbox?  What is best practice for displaying a photo?

Do I want to people to be able to download my presentations or embed them on the page using something like Slideshare or Speakerdeck?

Do I want an automatic news feed so I don’t have to index news items? Do I want it to be shared with other sites on campus? Do I want an RSS feed?

What about events? Do I want events to be auto archived after the event is over? Can calender.nd.edu sync with my website? Do I want it to be easily shared to social media?

Speaking of social media, how will I handle social media pages on my website? Can I get an feed from my twitter? Do I want people to see my Linkedin company profile, etc…

What about forms? How will people contact me through the website? Can they sign up of a newsletter? Do I want to have a newsletter? (Which I recommend)

What we usually find is that people make a selection of a CMS without really looking through the content or structure or audience or any of that. This should be done before you move forward.

3. Is the code up to standards?

Now, this can be difficult to understand sometimes but there are a lot of content management systems that generate bad code or too much code. Now there are lots of different languages out there but they all do basically the same thing. The code generate should be efficient and it should render your website to look the same on all the different “major” browsers (i.e. Firefox, Internet Explorer, Safari, Google Chrome) and their latest versions. If you don’t have an idea if the code is good, reach out to our web developers here and we’ll look it over for you. We’re not biased against other CMSes but we do dislike bad code and we’ll tell you if it’s generating crap or not.

4. How much can I afford?

There are lots of little costs besides just the main one of just buying the right CMS. So make sure you take those into account. Most of the time a company will hype the inital cost of the set-up and throw in the small costs later (after the project is already started).  Don’t let them do that.  Make sure you understand where and how is the website is going to be hosted, what kind of maintenance plan is provided, who provides upgrades and is there a cost involved to upgrade to the next version, what’s the development roadmap for this CMS, is it open-sourced (no one owns the code) or is it proprietary? How much does web support cost at an hourly rate? If it goes down, who do I call? If I break something, who can help me? What kind of back-up is there if something goes wrong? What do they consider their “up” time? What if I want to add another website or web page? All of these things have costs involved and you should understand that before buying anything. Also remember that if you are buying something, procurement will need to be involved as well.

5. Future proofing my website. Will the CMS provide mobile CSS or Responsive Design? Do I need a separate mobile website?

The CMS should have the ability to go mobile with your website via CSS at a basic level. If not, then don’t buy it. If you were at the mobile summit or attended Erik Runyon’s mobile brown bag, then you’ll understand that mobile is growing by leaps and bounds. Don’t lock yourself down to just a website when the rest of the world is going mobile.

Finally, what’s available on campus for Notre Dame.

[slideshare id=11943199&doc=cms-selection-guide-final-120309131206-phpapp02]

Well, there are several options for website content management systems. The university has decided to support two via Marketing Communications but you don’t have to pick them if they don’t meet your needs.

The two systems are:

Conductor Content Management System:
http://conductor.nd.edu built, supported and maintained by Marketing Communications: Web Team

WordPress Content Management System:
http://blogs.nd.edu built by WordPress, install and maintenance by Marketing Communications: Web Team

Other Content Management Systems:
Some individual colleges/schools/departments have implemented their own CMS solutions after conducting evaluations.

There is Drupal, Joomla, Ektron, and Plone to mention a few but I’m sure there are several that I don’t know about. If you want to contact the depts that have these CMSes, just send me an email at don.schindler@nd.edu

Good luck with your CMS selection.

And if I missed something here that you would like me to add or talk about, then drop me a line.


8 responses to “What’s the right web content management system (CMS) for you?”

  1. I have to say WordPress, its the best system to combine ease of use with complex function which as a website designer
    is important to me, it also has the best platform to build an SEO campaign around aswell as having great Ecommerce development features

  2. Julie moreno Avatar
    Julie moreno

    I am about to embark on building a website for my place of employment, a state psych hospital in NJ. It will be an internally hosted site (intranet). I am an art therapist and was a graphic designer before. I do digital art therapy and traditional with our patients. I have 4 iMac computers and am meeting with our IT dept. to discuss hosting and launching and maintaining.
    Can I begin this whole process using CS 5.5 illustrator, photoshop, etc. or do I really need to purchase something else right now?
    Your site is extreemly helpful. I am reading more.

  3. I agree with your point that people like things to be simple. If it is too complicated they avoid it. The tips that you have given are useful to me in various ways. I am going to use this to improve my website.

  4. There’s a decent open-source CMS called Wolf CMS (it used to be Frog CMS). It has quite a few plugins to describe almost every extension you talked about that you would need: http://www.wolfcms.org/extending

    The key thing though, is the community for Wolf CMS seems to be in good shape and growing.

  5. […] this is one of the 'templates' I designed for the layout, plus the color scheme is quite nice too…I'm putting the finishing touches to my upgraded Content Managment System. It's called siteBOSS and …This puppy is fabulous! I'll be releasing some video tutorials soon. It is of course all AJAX […]

  6. Everyone has different choices to choose a best CMS for website/blog. And For me WordPress its very simple and easy to use. Its is the best CMS for me.

  7. sotonye jude Avatar
    sotonye jude

    Everyone has different choices to choose a best CMS for website/blog. And For me WordPress its very simple and easy to use. Its is the best CMS for me. http://www.chopknuckles.com

  8. Allen cooper Avatar
    Allen cooper

    Only WordPress is the best and easy CMS which i have used for website and blog.I believe on quality work and try to make website user friendly.So that’s why it is the best CMS for me. http://blustandard.com/hosting.php

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *